Is there a clear line between minor damage and an accident-damaged car?
Not one laid down in law. In practice, minor damage is anything that only affects the surface: scratches, dents, a replaced bumper or mirror. As soon as load-bearing parts, the frame, axles or safety equipment were affected, the car is considered accident-damaged.
A second yardstick, common in practice, is the cost of the repair in relation to the vehicle’s value. Both yardsticks are interpretation, not law, and that is exactly why disputes arise here.
For you, this means: do not rely on a rule of thumb, rely on the paperwork. The repair invoice says what was done, and that answers the question.
Do I have to disclose accident damage when selling a car?
Yes, if you know about it. Anyone who conceals a known, significant defect acts fraudulently, and that overrides the warranty exclusion in the purchase contract. The buyer can then still bring claims years later. So write any known damage explicitly into the contract.
This is not a theoretical risk but the most common cause of disputes in private car sales. A sentence in the contract such as “Front end professionally repaired in 2023 after a rear-end collision, invoice attached” may cost you a few hundred francs on the price and save you a court case. Why “accident-free” in a contract is more than a word is explained in our guide Car purchase contract with template.
As a buyer, how do I spot repaired accident damage?
By uneven panel gaps between the doors, bonnet, boot lid and wings, by colour differences in raking light, by overspray on rubber seals and by bolt heads that clearly show tool marks. Unevenly worn tyres also point to bent suspension, and a look under the boot carpet reveals welds that do not belong there.
View the vehicle in daylight and when it is dry. If in doubt, an inspection by an independent body is worth it. The TCS and many garages offer a used-car check that costs a fraction of what overlooked damage costs. More on this in our guide to buying a used car.
How much does accident damage lower a car’s value?
That depends on what was affected and whether it is documented. Properly repaired, documented damage to a bolt-on part costs little. Damage to load-bearing parts costs a lot, and damage without paperwork costs the most, because the buyer assumes the worst case.
What your vehicle would be worth if the damage is left aside is calculated by our market value estimate. You have to subtract the discount for the damage from that, and that takes someone who has seen the vehicle. An online calculator cannot do that, and none should claim it can.
What does “write-off” mean, and is it the same thing?
No. A car is a write-off when the repair would cost more than the vehicle is worth. The insurer then pays out the value instead of the repair. Such a vehicle can still be repaired and resold, but must then be declared for what it is.
Take particular care with a vehicle that was settled as a write-off and then repaired. Ask for full documentation of the repair and have the car inspected before you buy. Without both, the price cannot be judged.
Is an accident-damaged car worth it for a garage?
Often, yes. Documented, properly repaired accident damage puts private buyers off far more than the car’s technical condition would justify. Anyone who can assess the damage buys such vehicles well below market value and resells them with the damage fully disclosed.
These are exactly the vehicles Prisradar finds: it checks every new listing against the market value and reports whatever is strikingly cheap. Judging whether the low price is justified stays with the expert, but the software does the finding.