Prisradar
Selling a carAll 4 articles

Selling to a garage or privately: the honest comparison

Privately you get more; selling to a garage is faster and safer. The difference is not a rip-off but the price of the reconditioning, warranty and time on the forecourt that the dealer takes on. Which route pays off depends on the car’s value, its condition and your time.

Prisradar editorial team6 questions

Cover image of the guide: Selling to a garage or privately: the honest comparison

How big is the difference in what I get for my car?

A dealer offers well below market value, because the whole margin they work from lies between their buying and their selling price. How big the gap is depends heavily on the car: for popular models it is smaller, for hard-to-sell ones much bigger.

We deliberately don’t give a general percentage here. It would be a guess. What you can do instead: have the market value of your car calculated and compare it with what a garage actually offers you. The difference is your concrete figure, not a rule of thumb.

Get two or three offers. They will differ, and by more than most people expect.

What exactly am I paying this difference for?

For four things the dealer takes off your hands:reconditioning the car, the statutory warranty towards the next buyer, the time the car stands on their forecourt and ties up capital, and the risk that a hidden defect turns up later.

Then there is what you save yourself: writing the listing, taking photos, answering calls, going along on test drives, negotiating, drawing up the contract and securing the money. Add it all up and you quickly get to several working days.

Which cars are worth selling privately?

Cars in good condition with a complete service history, a popular model and a value at which the difference is noticeable. For a car in the mid five-figure range, the effort is almost always worth it; for a used car worth a few thousand francs, it rarely is.

A second rule of thumb: the more you can document, the more a private sale brings in. A service book, invoices and a fresh MFK inspection take away exactly the risk for which a private buyer would otherwise demand a discount.

When is a garage the better choice?

When the car has a defect, when the inspection is due, when it is a hard-to-sell model, or when you need to get rid of it quickly. In all these cases, a private buyer deducts so much for the risk that the gap to the dealer’s offer melts away.

The same applies if you are buying another car from the same garage anyway. The trade-in is then part of an overall deal, and the amount credited is hard to compare on its own. In that case, ask for the price of the new car without a trade-in, otherwise you won’t know what you are really getting.

What about car-buying services that make an offer online?

They are the fastest route and the one with the lowest return. Their business is buying in volume and reselling, and they calculate accordingly. The online offer is usually non-binding and is corrected downwards once more when they inspect the car.

Go to such an appointment with your own figure in mind, not expecting to get the online offer. If the price drops sharply on the spot and the reasoning is thin, you are free to leave. You are under no obligation.

What does all this mean for a dealer on the buying side?

That cars with a defect, an inspection due or a hard-to-sell model can be had cheaply where the private seller gets stuck. If you can handle the inspection and repairs more cheaply than a private buyer, these are exactly the cars you buy below their value.

That is exactly what Prisradar is built for: it checks every new listing on the big Swiss marketplaces against the market value and reports what is listed too cheaply. How the market value is worked out is explained on the vehicle valuation page.

Bar chart: used cars below market value stay online for a median of 18 days, cars at market price 58 days.
From our own records: every listing that goes offline, with the last price it had. Recalculated every six hours.

What is your car worth today?

Enter make, model, year and mileage and you see the market value from the used cars currently for sale in Switzerland. Free; you only confirm your e-mail address.

Value the car

Secure your place on the waiting list

Seats are limited. If you’re on the waiting list, you have a chance of getting one.

We only use your address for the waiting list and the launch of Prisradar. More in the privacy policy.